COMPLETED
Decision date
Case register
This page was updated3 weeks ago
The Commission has declined an application from Foodstuffs North Island Limited and Foodstuffs South Island Limited, for clearance to merge. Foodstuffs North Island Limited and Foodstuffs South Island Limited have lodged an appeal at the Wellington High Court of the Commission’s determination declining clearance.
Foodstuffs North Island Limited; Foodstuffs South Island Limited
Parties
Foodstuffs North Island Limited; Foodstuffs South Island Limited
Category
Merger application
Sub-category
Clearance
Act/Section
Commerce Act s 66
Industry
Retail - other
Status
Closed
Outcome
Merger declined
Case decision number
[2024] NZCC 22
Date opened
15 December 2023
Date closed
30 September 2024
-
01 Oct 2024
-
30 Sep 2024
COMPLETED
Date closed – Merger declined
-
23 Aug 2024
COMPLETED
Cross-submissions on SoUI
-
12 Aug 2024
COMPLETED
Submissions on SoUI
-
16 Jul 2024
COMPLETED
SoUI published
-
21 Jun 2024
COMPLETED
Decision date (extension to 1 October 2024)
-
31 May 2024
COMPLETED
Decision date (extension to 21 June 2024)
-
03 May 2024
COMPLETED
Cross-submissions on SoI
-
30 Apr 2024
COMPLETED
Cross-submissions on SoI (extension to 3 May 2024)
-
18 Apr 2024
COMPLETED
Submissions on SoI
-
04 Apr 2024
COMPLETED
Decision date (extension until 31 May 2024)
-
04 Apr 2024
COMPLETED
SoI published
-
05 Mar 2024
COMPLETED
Decision date (extension to 4 April 2024)
-
01 Feb 2024
COMPLETED
Submissions on SoPI
-
18 Jan 2024
COMPLETED
SoPI published
-
15 Dec 2023
COMPLETED
Date opened
- [2024] NZCC 24 – Foodstuffs merger – executive summary of clearance determination – 30 September 2024pdf - 159 KB | Published on October 23 2024
- [2024] NZCC 24 – Foodstuffs merger – clearance determination – 30 September 2024pdf - 3 MB | Published on October 23 2024
- Lisa Asher – cross-submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – updated 29 August 2024pdf - 3 MB | Published on September 02 2024
- Dr Robert Hamlin – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 29 August 2024pdf - 356 KB | Published on August 30 2024
- FSNI and FSSI – cross-submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 26 August 2024pdf - 394 KB | Published on August 27 2024
- FSNI and FSSI – appendix 2 of cross-submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues Dusseldorf Competition Economics expert opinion – 26 August 2024pdf - 309 KB | Published on August 27 2024
- FSNI and FSSI – appendices 3 to 7 of cross-submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 26 August 2024pdf - 271 KB | Published on August 27 2024
- Grocery Action Group – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 16 August 2024pdf - 277 KB | Published on August 19 2024
- Tim Hazeldine – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 12 August 2024pdf - 722 KB | Published on August 16 2024
- Lisa Asher – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 15 August 2024pdf - 572 KB | Published on August 16 2024
- FSNI and FSSI – appendices 2 to 20 of submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 13 August 2024pdf - 1 MB | Published on August 15 2024
- FSNI and FSSI – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 13 August 2024pdf - 2 MB | Published on August 15 2024
- Houston Kemp – economic effects of proposed merger of FSNI and FSSI – review of statement of unresolved issues – 13 August 2024pdf - 834 KB | Published on August 15 2024
- Rob Beard – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 9 August 2024pdf - 375 KB | Published on August 15 2024
- Pernod Ricard – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 12 August 2024pdf - 145 KB | Published on August 14 2024
- NZ Specialist Cheesemakers Association – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 12 August 2024pdf - 272 KB | Published on August 14 2024
- Murray Edridge – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 6 August 2024pdf - 557 KB | Published on August 14 2024
- Monopoly Watch – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 12 August 2024pdf - 161 KB | Published on August 14 2024
- Food and Grocery Council – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 12 August 2024pdf - 155 KB | Published on August 14 2024
- Ernie Newman – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 12 August 2024pdf - 189 KB | Published on August 14 2024
- Beverley Moore – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 26 July 2024pdf - 633 KB | Published on August 14 2024
- Anonymous L – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 12 August 2024pdf - 656 KB | Published on August 14 2024
- Anonymous K – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 11 August 2024pdf - 430 KB | Published on August 14 2024
- Anonymous J – submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of unresolved issues – 22 July 2024pdf - 95 KB | Published on August 14 2024
- FSNI and FSSI – Statement of Unresolved Issues – 16 July 2024pdf - 1 MB | Published on July 16 2024
- FSNI and FSSI – cross-submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of issues – 31 May 2024pdf - 163 KB | Published on June 04 2024
- Anonymous I – Submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of issues – 1 May 2024pdf - 549 KB | Published on May 13 2024
- FSNI and FSSI – Cross-submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of issues – 6 May 2024pdf - 276 KB | Published on May 13 2024
- The Warehouse Group – Cross-submission in response to FSNI and FSSI statement of issues – 10 May 2024pdf - 219 KB | Published on May 13 2024
- Food and Grocery Council – submission in response to Statement of Issues – 26 April 2024pdf - 658 KB | Published on April 29 2024
- Lisa Asher – submission in response to Statement of Issues – 25 April 2024pdf - 142 KB | Published on April 29 2024
- Houston Kemp – economic effects of proposed merger of FSNI and FSSI review of statement of issues – 26 April 2024pdf - 521 KB | Published on April 29 2024
- Grocery Action Group – submission in response to Statement of Issues – received 24 April 2024pdf - 476 KB | Published on April 29 2024
- FSNI and FSSI – submission in response to Statement of Issues – 26 April 2024pdf - 673 KB | Published on April 29 2024
- Anonymous H – submission in response to Statement of Issues – 18 April 2024pdf - 434 KB | Published on April 29 2024
- Anonymous G – submission in response to Statement of Issues – 18 April 2024pdf - 116 KB | Published on April 29 2024
- Justin Jeans – submission in response to Statement of Issues – 20 April 2024pdf - 526 KB | Published on April 23 2024
- Glenn East – submission in response to Statement of Issues – 5 April 2024pdf - 440 KB | Published on April 23 2024
- Anonymous D – submission in response to Statement of Issues – 6 April 2024pdf - 517 KB | Published on April 16 2024
- Anonymous F – submission in response to Statement of Issues – 13 April 2024pdf - 440 KB | Published on April 16 2024
- Anonymous E – submission in response to Statement of Issues – 7 April 2024pdf - 437 KB | Published on April 16 2024
- FSNI and FSSI – Statement of Issues – 4 April 2024pdf - 429 KB | Published on April 04 2024
- Houston Kemp – Economic effects of the proposed merger of Foodstuffs North Island and Foodstuffs South Island – 7 March 2024pdf - 641 KB | Published on March 08 2024
- Foodstuffs – Cross-submission in response to Statement of Preliminary Issues – 7 March 2024pdf - 530 KB | Published on March 08 2024
- FSNI and FSSI – Northelia NZ – submission in response to Statement of Preliminary Issues – 27 February 2024pdf - 128 KB | Published on February 27 2024
- FSNI and FSSI – Monopoly Watch – submission in response to Statement of Preliminary Issues – 27 February 2024pdf - 355 KB | Published on February 27 2024
- FSNI and FSSI – Food and Grocery Council – submission on Statement of Preliminary Issues – 19 February 2024pdf - 850 KB | Published on February 21 2024
- FSNI and FSSI merger – Lisa Asher – submission in response to Statement of Preliminary Issues – 9 February 2024pdf - 4 MB | Published on February 16 2024
- FSNI and FSSI merger – The Warehouse – submission in response to Statement of Preliminary Issues – 9 February 2024pdf - 1 MB | Published on February 15 2024
- FSNI and FSSI merger – Grocery Action Group submission in response to Statement of Preliminary Issues – 9 February 2024pdf - 200 KB | Published on February 13 2024
- Ernie Newman submission on SoPI – revised 5 February 2024pdf - 170 KB | Published on February 05 2024
- Habilis NZ – submission in response to Statement of Preliminary Issues – 1 February 2024pdf - 167 KB | Published on February 02 2024
- Anonymous C – submission in response to Statement of Preliminary Issues – 25 January 2024pdf - 658 KB | Published on February 02 2024
- Anonymous B – submission in response to Statement of Preliminary Issues – 23 January 2024pdf - 604 KB | Published on January 31 2024
- Anonymous A – submission in response to Statement of Preliminary Issues – 22 January 2024pdf - 458 KB | Published on January 31 2024
- FSNI FSSI – Statement of Preliminary Issues – 18 January 2024pdf - 247 KB | Published on January 18 2024
- FSNI FSSI – clearance application – 14 December 2023pdf - 2 MB | Published on December 18 2023
Documents (57)
-
01 Oct 2024
-
16 Jul 2024
-
21 Jun 2024
-
20 May 2024
-
04 Apr 2024
-
18 Mar 2024
-
18 Jan 2024
-
18 Dec 2023